On the early hours of June 4th, shortly after police arrested Jessie Misskelley Jr., three officers enforcing a search warrant of Jessie’s trailer, sat down and talked with Jessie Misskelley Sr., and his live in girlfriend, Lee Rush while they waited for crime scene investigators to arrive.
During the course of talking with the officers, Rush stated, “I knew that something was wrong, a few nights ago little Jessie was in his room crying so loud and sobbing so hard that it woke me up, I went in and asked him what was wrong? His reply was that his girl friend was moving to Florida.”
A few moments later, Rush again repeated her statements, saying Jessie had recently over the course of several nights had mysterious crying fits and waking nightmares. And every time she walked into Jessie Jr.’s room and asked him what was wrong, he repeated that he was upset over how his girlfriend Susie Brewer might move away to Florida.
“She told us it happened a number of times, and that she could not believe his girlfriends’ moving would cause that kind of hysterical behavior, but that little Jessie had been acting strange.”
Immediately during an interview for the documentary Paradise Lost, while being filmed sitting in the living room of their trailer, Jessie Misskelley Sr. and his girlfriend, Lee Rush openly argued about Jessie’s guilt, as Rush repeatedly seems to question Jessie’s innocence.
Lee Rush: “We don’t know what the truth is, but when it really gets down to brass tax. His daddy and I are gonna look him square in the eyes and say ‘son did you do this? D-were you even there?’ That’s when we will believe.”
Jessie Sr.: “Well, if he told me he did it, which I don’t believe he did, but if he told me he did it, he’d have to do his time. Suffer the consequences.”
Lee Rush: “If he admits to this he would be strictly on his own, we wouldn’t even send him a dollar for a pack of cigarettes.”
Jessie Sr.: “No, no, you’re wrong there.
Lee Rush: “Yes we would.”
Jessie Sr.: “No I would. He’s my son! I’ll send him money, but he will have to do his time.”
Lee Rush: “I wouldn’t give him a nickle.”
Jessie Sr.: “He’s my son.”
Lee Rush: “Now We could be talking about-“
Jessie Sr.: “He’s my flesh and blood!”
Lee Rush: “We could be talking about my son.”
Jessie Sr.: “Well…
Lee Rush: “If my son did something that horrible that, I wouldn’t give him a nickle, let him suffer.”
Jessie Sr.: “You can’t turn your blood away.”
Lee Rush: “I don’t know how you say you could and we’re gonna have a problem over this.”
Jessie Sr.: “But I know how it is being up in jail without having anything.”
Lee Rush: “Well that’s beside the point, if he, if he’s guilty, if he’s guilty of doing this to these little boys, no!
Jessie Sr.: “But he’s not.”
Lee Rush: “Well, I’m saying he’s not too, but if he happens to be, if it’s proven, no! forget it, no, no.”
Jessie Sr.: “But I don’t believe he did it. I’ll never believe he did it.”
Shortly after this filmed incident, the relationship with Jessie Misskelley Sr. and Lee Rush came to an end.